International Trade: Some Key Issues
International Trade: Some Key Issues
International trade has often played a central role in the historical experience of the developing world. In recent years, much of the attention to trade and development issues has been focused on understanding the spectacular export success of East Asia. Taiwan, South Korea, and other East Asian economies pioneered this strategy, which has been successfully followed by their much larger neighbor, China. The experiences of these countries are an important plot in the unfolding trade and development drama and will be examined later in the chapter. At the same time, throughout Africa, the Middle East, and Latin America, primary product exports have traditionally accounted for a sizable proportion of individual gross domestic products. In some of the smaller countries, a substantial percentage of the economy’s monetary income is derived from the overseas sale of agricultural and other primary products or commodities such as coffee, cotton, cacao, sugar, palm oil, bauxite, and copper. In the special circumstances of the oil-producing nations in the Persian Gulf and elsewhere, the sale of unrefined and refined petroleum products to countries throughout the world accounts for over 70% of their national incomes. But unlike the oil producing states and successfully industrializing countries like South Korea, Taiwan, and now China, many developing countries must still depend on nonmineral primary-product exports for a relatively large fraction of their foreign-exchange earnings. This is a particularly serious problem in sub-Saharan Africa. Because the markets and prices for these exports are often unstable primary-product export dependence carries with it a degree of risk and uncertainty that few nations desire. This is an important issue because despite strength since 2002 and some rebounding after the 2008 crisis, the long-term trend for prices of primary goods is downward, as well as very volatile (as we examine later in this section). Some African countries, including Mali, Niger, Burkina Faso, and Burundi, continue to receive 8% or less of their merchandise export earnings from manufactures (none of them received more than 3% of their export earnings from fossil fuels in 2005). Nigeria received 98% of its export earnings from fossil fuels in 2005. Indeed, some developing countries continue to receive at least two-fifths of their export earnings from one or two agricultural or nonfuel mineral products. And as noted by David Harvey and his coauthors, “For 40 countries, the production of three or fewer commodities explains all export earnings.”4 And UNCTAD reported in 2006 that “out of 141 developing countries, 95 are more than 50% dependent on commodity exports . . . In most subSaharan African countries, the figure is 80%.”5 In addition to their export dependence, many developing countries rely, generally to an even greater extent, on the importation of raw materials, machinery, capital goods, intermediate producer goods, and consumer products to fuel their industrial expansion and satisfy the rising consumption aspirations of their people. For a majority of developing nations, import demands exceeded their capacity to generate sufficient revenues from the sale of exports for much of the post–World War II period. This led to chronic deficits on their balance of payments position vis-à-vis the rest of the world. Whereas such deficits on the current account (an excess of import payments over export receipts for goods and services) were compensated for on their balance of payments table by a surplus on the capital account (a receipt of foreign private and public lending and investment in excess of repayment of principal and interest on former loans and investments), the debt burden of repaying earlier international loans and investments often becomes acute. In a number of developing countries, severe deficits on current and capital accounts have led to a depletion of international monetary reserves, currency instability, and a slowdown in economic growth. In the 1980s and 1990s, this combination of rising trade deficits, growing foreign debts, accelerated capital flight, and diminished international reserves led to the widespread adoption of fiscal and monetary austerity measures, especially in Africa and Latin America (often with the involvement of the International Monetary Fund), which may have further exacerbated the slowdown in economic growth and the worsening of poverty and unemployment in much of the developing world. These various concepts of international economics will be explained in more detail later in this chapter and in the next. Here the point is merely that a chronic excess of foreign expenditures over receipts (which may have nothing to do with a developing country’s inability to handle its financial affairs but rather may be related to its vulnerability to global economic disturbances) can significantly retard development efforts. It can also greatly limit a poor nation’s ability to determine and pursue its most desirable economic strategies. Many indebted countries went into surplus as they paid down some of their debt. In the new century, a pattern of trade surpluses has strengthened for many though by no means all developing countries. Developing countries have sought to avoid repeats of the crisis conditions of Latin America in the 1980s, sub-Saharan Africa in the 1980s and 1990s, and East Asia in 1997–98. The sudden collapse of export earnings during the 2008 financial crisis provided a glimpse of the dangers, although the global economy quickly moved back toward its apparently unsustainable imbalances. This pattern carries its own risks; for example, it means that developing countries are effectively exporting capital, and it leaves economies vulnerable to a sharp correction when the large and chronic U.S. balance of payments deficits are inevitably reversed.6 But international trade and finance must be understood in a much broader perspective than simply the intercountry flow of commodities and financial resources. By opening their economies and societies to global trade and commerce and by looking outward to the rest of the world, developing countries invite not only the international transfer of goods, services, and financial resources but also the developmental or antidevelopmental influences of the transfer of production technologies; consumption patterns; institutional and organizational arrangements; educational, health, and social systems; and the more general values, ideals, and lifestyles of the developed nations of the world. The impact of such technological, economic, social, and cultural transfers on the character of the development process can be either consistent or inconsistent with broader development objectives. Much will depend on the nature of the political, social, and institutional structure of the recipient country and its development priorities. Whether it is best for developing countries to look primarily outward (as single economies or as blocs) and promote more exports, either passively or actively; to emphasize looking inward and substitute domestic production for imports, as the protectionists and cultural nationalists propose; or to be simultaneously and strategically outward- and inward-looking in their international economic policies cannot be stated a priori. Individual nations must appraise their present and prospective situations in the world community realistically in the light of their specific development objectives. Only thus can they determine how to design the most beneficial trade strategy. Although participation in the world economy is all but inevitable, there is ample room for policy choice about what kind of participation to promote and what policy strategies to pursue. As you will see, WTO membership comes with prohibitions or restrictions on some policies, but there remains a great deal of scope for policy choice for developing countries.
International trade has often played a central role in the historical experience of the developing world. In recent years, much of the attention to trade and development issues has been focused on understanding the spectacular export success of East Asia. Taiwan, South Korea, and other East Asian economies pioneered this strategy, which has been successfully followed by their much larger neighbor, China. The experiences of these countries are an important plot in the unfolding trade and development drama and will be examined later in the chapter. At the same time, throughout Africa, the Middle East, and Latin America, primary product exports have traditionally accounted for a sizable proportion of individual gross domestic products. In some of the smaller countries, a substantial percentage of the economy’s monetary income is derived from the overseas sale of agricultural and other primary products or commodities such as coffee, cotton, cacao, sugar, palm oil, bauxite, and copper. In the special circumstances of the oil-producing nations in the Persian Gulf and elsewhere, the sale of unrefined and refined petroleum products to countries throughout the world accounts for over 70% of their national incomes. But unlike the oil producing states and successfully industrializing countries like South Korea, Taiwan, and now China, many developing countries must still depend on nonmineral primary-product exports for a relatively large fraction of their foreign-exchange earnings. This is a particularly serious problem in sub-Saharan Africa. Because the markets and prices for these exports are often unstable primary-product export dependence carries with it a degree of risk and uncertainty that few nations desire. This is an important issue because despite strength since 2002 and some rebounding after the 2008 crisis, the long-term trend for prices of primary goods is downward, as well as very volatile (as we examine later in this section). Some African countries, including Mali, Niger, Burkina Faso, and Burundi, continue to receive 8% or less of their merchandise export earnings from manufactures (none of them received more than 3% of their export earnings from fossil fuels in 2005). Nigeria received 98% of its export earnings from fossil fuels in 2005. Indeed, some developing countries continue to receive at least two-fifths of their export earnings from one or two agricultural or nonfuel mineral products. And as noted by David Harvey and his coauthors, “For 40 countries, the production of three or fewer commodities explains all export earnings.”4 And UNCTAD reported in 2006 that “out of 141 developing countries, 95 are more than 50% dependent on commodity exports . . . In most subSaharan African countries, the figure is 80%.”5 In addition to their export dependence, many developing countries rely, generally to an even greater extent, on the importation of raw materials, machinery, capital goods, intermediate producer goods, and consumer products to fuel their industrial expansion and satisfy the rising consumption aspirations of their people. For a majority of developing nations, import demands exceeded their capacity to generate sufficient revenues from the sale of exports for much of the post–World War II period. This led to chronic deficits on their balance of payments position vis-à-vis the rest of the world. Whereas such deficits on the current account (an excess of import payments over export receipts for goods and services) were compensated for on their balance of payments table by a surplus on the capital account (a receipt of foreign private and public lending and investment in excess of repayment of principal and interest on former loans and investments), the debt burden of repaying earlier international loans and investments often becomes acute. In a number of developing countries, severe deficits on current and capital accounts have led to a depletion of international monetary reserves, currency instability, and a slowdown in economic growth. In the 1980s and 1990s, this combination of rising trade deficits, growing foreign debts, accelerated capital flight, and diminished international reserves led to the widespread adoption of fiscal and monetary austerity measures, especially in Africa and Latin America (often with the involvement of the International Monetary Fund), which may have further exacerbated the slowdown in economic growth and the worsening of poverty and unemployment in much of the developing world. These various concepts of international economics will be explained in more detail later in this chapter and in the next. Here the point is merely that a chronic excess of foreign expenditures over receipts (which may have nothing to do with a developing country’s inability to handle its financial affairs but rather may be related to its vulnerability to global economic disturbances) can significantly retard development efforts. It can also greatly limit a poor nation’s ability to determine and pursue its most desirable economic strategies. Many indebted countries went into surplus as they paid down some of their debt. In the new century, a pattern of trade surpluses has strengthened for many though by no means all developing countries. Developing countries have sought to avoid repeats of the crisis conditions of Latin America in the 1980s, sub-Saharan Africa in the 1980s and 1990s, and East Asia in 1997–98. The sudden collapse of export earnings during the 2008 financial crisis provided a glimpse of the dangers, although the global economy quickly moved back toward its apparently unsustainable imbalances. This pattern carries its own risks; for example, it means that developing countries are effectively exporting capital, and it leaves economies vulnerable to a sharp correction when the large and chronic U.S. balance of payments deficits are inevitably reversed.6 But international trade and finance must be understood in a much broader perspective than simply the intercountry flow of commodities and financial resources. By opening their economies and societies to global trade and commerce and by looking outward to the rest of the world, developing countries invite not only the international transfer of goods, services, and financial resources but also the developmental or antidevelopmental influences of the transfer of production technologies; consumption patterns; institutional and organizational arrangements; educational, health, and social systems; and the more general values, ideals, and lifestyles of the developed nations of the world. The impact of such technological, economic, social, and cultural transfers on the character of the development process can be either consistent or inconsistent with broader development objectives. Much will depend on the nature of the political, social, and institutional structure of the recipient country and its development priorities. Whether it is best for developing countries to look primarily outward (as single economies or as blocs) and promote more exports, either passively or actively; to emphasize looking inward and substitute domestic production for imports, as the protectionists and cultural nationalists propose; or to be simultaneously and strategically outward- and inward-looking in their international economic policies cannot be stated a priori. Individual nations must appraise their present and prospective situations in the world community realistically in the light of their specific development objectives. Only thus can they determine how to design the most beneficial trade strategy. Although participation in the world economy is all but inevitable, there is ample room for policy choice about what kind of participation to promote and what policy strategies to pursue. As you will see, WTO membership comes with prohibitions or restrictions on some policies, but there remains a great deal of scope for policy choice for developing countries.
Comments
Post a Comment